Professional Practice Architecture Practice Test

What is a potential response from Architect "A" regarding liability for roof leaks?

1. He is responsible for contractor errors

2. He should not be liable since he did not perform the work

3. The couple must take responsibility

4. Liability should be shared

The correct answer is: He should not be liable since he did not perform the work

In this context, Architect "A" might argue that he should not be held liable for roof leaks because he did not personally perform the construction work. This perspective is grounded in the role of an architect, who typically provides design services and oversight rather than executing the physical labor involved in construction. Architects are generally not responsible for the day-to-day actions of contractors or their working methods, unless there are specific contractual obligations that define responsibility for construction defects. When assessing the liability issues, it's important to recognize that most jurisdictions hold contractors accountable for the quality of their workmanship. If Architect "A" designed the roof and specified materials and practices, he may still face scrutiny, but his argument hinges on the distinction between oversight and direct involvement in construction activities. This approach emphasizes the allocation of risk and responsibility within the construction process, wherein different parties (architects, contractors, and clients) have specific roles, and liabilities can be delineated based on those roles. Such distinctions help clarify expectations and facilitate discussions on accountability in construction projects.